---
title: The middleman just changed | BullCity AI
description: AI agents got wallets and phone lines, and Nvidia posted a record quarter without Jensen Huang
image: https://bullcity.ai/hubfs/magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-smalltown-diner-counter_cpgZuxY0eP.png
---

[Skip to content](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-48#main-content)

![Bull City AI | Durham Circuit Bull](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/freepik_assistant_1759412406030-1.png?width=1344&height=768&name=freepik_assistant_1759412406030-1.png)Homepage

- [Services](https://bullcity.ai#services)
- [About](https://bullcity.ai#about)
- [Newsletter](https://bullcity.ai/blog)

[Stay up to date](https://bullcity.ai/#contact)

- [Services](https://bullcity.ai#services)
- [About](https://bullcity.ai#about)
- [Newsletter](https://bullcity.ai/blog)

[Stay up to date](https://bullcity.ai/#contact)

![Bull City AI weekly newsletter illustration](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-smalltown-diner-counter_cpgZuxY0eP.png?width=3840&height=2160&name=magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-smalltown-diner-counter_cpgZuxY0eP.png)

# The middleman just changed

![Daniel](https://7528315.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net/hub/7528315/hubfs/raw_assets/public/mV0_d-cms-elevate-theme_hubspot/elevate/images/avatar-placeholder.jpg?width=48&height=48&name=avatar-placeholder.jpg)

 Daniel

November 18, 2026

Last week the public set the price. This week the question moved one seat over, to whoever stands between the buyer and the seller.

In four days OpenAI let businesses claim their profiles inside ChatGPT, then handed its agents a wallet. Meta's Muse started phoning businesses for paying customers. And United Airlines said AI agents can look at its flights but can't buy them. United's CEO, Scott Kirby, told The Wall Street Journal why. "I don't want to create another middleman."

Meanwhile the most important middleman in AI walked out the door. Jensen Huang resigned from Nvidia last Thursday. Last night Nvidia reported $115.8 billion in quarterly revenue without him.

I think these are the same story. The spot between a customer and a business, the one a receptionist or a sales rep used to hold, is starting to be filled by software. And Nvidia is finding out how much of its business ran through one person who sat across the table from its biggest customers. In both cases the middleman changed, and the open question is who the new one works for.

![Bull City AI weekly newsletter illustration](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-smalltown-diner-counter_cpgZuxY0eP.png?width=1200)

## The Big Story: Your Next Customer Has a Wallet and a Phone Line

On Tuesday, Nov. 10, OpenAI opened Businesses in ChatGPT in beta. Through a new Business Hub, a company can claim the profile ChatGPT already shows for it, correct the details, and see how often it gets mentioned and how many people click through to its website. Owners pass an ID check with Persona first. Local stores and restaurants can only claim a listing that already exists in the U.S. Eligible U.S. online sellers can also publish a Business Agent that answers customer questions. OpenAI's own page adds, "Claiming does not guarantee higher placement or sales."

On Thursday, TechCrunch reported that Muse can now place calls to U.S. businesses for paid subscribers, with plans starting at $20 a month. Meta's pitch is the calls you dread, like the DMV or the cable company. TechCrunch also observed that plenty of businesses hang up the moment they realize nobody human is on the line. TechCrunch offered that as an observation and didn't cite any data.

On Friday OpenAI introduced ChatGPT Wallet, which lets its always-on agents, the ones it calls dots, finish a purchase for you. American Express, Mastercard and Visa are partners. The store gets a payment token instead of your card number, and every purchase needs your Face ID or Touch ID. At launch it's limited to some U.S. Pro subscribers, and CNBC reported OpenAI is taking no cut of transactions for now. OpenAI also warned retailers that their fraud systems may decline legitimate agent purchases.

The traffic is real, if early. HUMAN Security's October report, published Nov. 9, found that agent requests on the sites it protects grew 2.6 times in a month and roughly eight times since August, according to PPC Land. Meta and OpenAI sent about 89% of it, and Muse alone sent 59%. MediaPost reported that 85% of those requests go straight to product and search pages. Those figures cover only sites that use HUMAN. Andreessen Horowitz partners Olivia and Justine Moore call this the B2A economy, business to agent, and argue that companies that built "walls to keep bots out" will now have to compete for the bots' business.

United built the wall anyway. On Wednesday, Nov. 11, it said it is blocking unauthorized third-party AI agents from booking flights, changing tickets or touching MileagePlus accounts, both on its own site and through travel agencies. It pointed to shared passwords, purchases nobody meant to make, and federal rules like the check-in step where a passenger confirms there's nothing banned in the bag. Delta has sounded more open, letting assistants book once they're authenticated, with extra safeguards for sensitive trips, according to Thrifty Traveler.

All of this is still small. The wallet is Pro only and asks for your face every time. Muse calls get hung up on. Thrifty Traveler noted United says it isn't seeing many agent bookings yet, which makes this the cheapest possible moment to close the door. And with two companies sending nine in ten agent requests, getting ready for agents mostly means getting ready for Meta and OpenAI.

**My take:** In #045 I said the agent fight would come down to a badge or a locked door, and I bet on the badge. This week OpenAI started issuing them, as verified profiles and payment tokens, while United went with the lock. I still think the badge wins, because customers will go wherever the errand takes the fewest taps. The catch is that OpenAI is the one issuing them. A ChatGPT profile is a listing on someone else's shelf, and in #046 I said any channel where someone else decides whether people reach you is rented. Kirby's line is honest about that. What he's protecting is his direct line to travelers, the same collision I wrote about in #044 between agents and businesses that earn money from friction. For this week, claim your profile, since someone else can try to if you don't. Then ask ChatGPT about your business the way a customer would and read what it says, because the dashboard won't show you.

## The Other Big Story: Nvidia Lost Its Founder and Posted Its Best Quarter Anyway

Last week I wrote up the board's investigation into reports that Huang had been targeted by a foreign intelligence effort. By then he had already admitted to employees that he had an affair with a business executive whom, according to The New York Times, U.S. intelligence believed was gathering information for Beijing. China denied the espionage claim. Reuters then reported that Huang had misled Nvidia's general counsel and other leaders about the relationship, and separately that he'd had an intimate relationship with an Nvidia employee.

The board met Wednesday. On Thursday, Nov. 12, Nvidia announced that Huang had resigned as president, CEO and director after 33 years. CFO Colette Kress is interim CEO and keeps the finance job. Harvey Jones, a director since 1993, became the first board chair and is leading the search. The stock fell nearly 12% early Thursday and was down as much as 19% from the prior Friday, more than $855 billion in market value, according to TechCrunch. Huang owns about 3.5%, with no supervoting shares, and ran the place with about 60 direct reports and no formal succession plan.

On Sunday the Financial Times reported that Huang has talked with confidants about coming back. Altimeter's Brad Gerstner and Atreides' Gavin Baker, whose funds held about $2.13 billion of Nvidia stock as of June, wrote to the board asking for a slow search that keeps open "the potential return of Jensen Huang." Neither Huang nor Nvidia has confirmed any of it. Admitting an affair doesn't establish that he shared anything he shouldn't have, and the investigation is still open.

Nvidia's results came out last night. Revenue was $115.8 billion, up 103% from a year ago, against Wall Street's estimate of about $109 billion and Nvidia's own guide of $108 billion. Net income was $65.3 billion. Vera Rubin, the new platform, brought in nearly $20 billion in its first quarter of shipments. Nvidia guided to $130 billion for this quarter, excluding any China data center sales, and Kress said it is no longer shipping licensed Hopper chips there. It also raised its growth target for next fiscal year to about 75%.

The $130 billion guide covers 14 weeks instead of the usual 13, and analyst Ian Cutress worked out that it's closer to 4% growth once you adjust. Kress called the guided margin of 71% to 72% the bottom. Nvidia's guarantees for the OpenAI-linked Ohio campus can reach $105 billion starting in fiscal 2029, with nothing paid so far, and Bernstein's Stacy Rasgon pressed her on new language that makes some cloud commitments depend on the customer getting financing. Jones wouldn't discuss the resignation on the call. Kress said it's "business as usual."

**My take:** In #032 I called Nvidia the system, and last week I said a system shouldn't hinge on one person. The quarter held up, but it ended Oct. 25, before any of this happened, so it tells us little about Nvidia without him. A big part of Huang's job was sitting across the table from customers and governments. Whether Nvidia keeps landing deals like the Ohio guarantee without him won't show up in results for a few quarters. Sixty direct reports, no named successor and no board chair until last week is a lot of risk to hang on one person, and the board carried it for years. If your own AI plans depend on one vendor's founder picking up the phone, write down what you'd do if someone else answered.

## Quick Hits

- **Anthropic prices its IPO tonight, and demand looks heavy.** The usual disclosure applies, since Claude drafts this newsletter. Bloomberg reported Tuesday that Anthropic is guiding investors to the top of its $70 to $78 range or above, after reporting last week that orders ran about six times the shares on offer. At the top, plus the $26 billion supplier placement, the deal raises $90.4 billion. Keep in mind that IPO order books run high, because funds ask for more shares than they expect to get. [Read the Bloomberg report](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-17/anthropic-is-said-to-guide-ipo-price-to-top-of-range-or-above)
- **Anthropic also shipped a new top model nine days ago.** Claude Fable 5.2 and Mythos 5.2 arrived Nov. 9, two versions of the same model, with Mythos still limited to verified organizations. Anthropic says output is up to 30% faster than 5.1 and API prices are 20% lower. It also says more than 90% of the changes merged into its core codebase are now written by Claude with human guidance. Anthropic made that claim the week before its IPO, and nobody outside the company has checked it. [Read it at 9to5Mac](https://9to5mac.com/2026/11/09/anthropic-upgrades-claude-with-new-fable-5-2-model-details-here/)
- **Google's new fast model is cheap, and its big ones double in price Dec. 1.** Gemini 4 Hydrogen launched Nov. 12 at $1.50 per million input tokens and $7.50 per million output. Gemini 4 Carbon went generally available Nov. 10 at an introductory $2 and $10, and both Carbon and Argon move to $4 and $20 on Dec. 1. Budget for the step if you built on the intro price. [Read it at FourWeekMBA](https://fourweekmba.com/ai-gemini-4-hydrogen-launches-at-2x-gemini-3-8-flashs-price/)
- **Alibaba's next flagship comes with an expiration date.** Qwen4-Max went into preview Nov. 11 with a million-token context window, available only through Alibaba's Token Plan subscription. There's no benchmark table or model card yet, and Alibaba retires the preview on Nov. 25, so anything built on it will have to move. [Read the release notes at AI TLDR](https://ai-tldr.dev/releases/qwen-qwen4-max-preview/)
- **Four nonprofits sued five labs to freeze frontier AI.** Public Citizen, the Irreplaceable Education Fund, Heat Initiative and the Alliance for Secure AI filed suit Nov. 12 in San Francisco Superior Court against Anthropic, Google, Meta, OpenAI and SpaceXSI. They're using California's unfair competition law and public nuisance claims, and they cite the sandbox escapes I've covered since July. A court-ordered freeze is unlikely, but if the case reaches discovery, the labs' internal incident records could come out. [Read it at Al Jazeera](https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/12/us-nonprofits-sue-tech-giants-to-halt-ai-development)

## Hot Takes

- **OpenAI will charge for agent checkout eventually.** OpenAI takes no cut of agent purchases at launch. App stores and delivery apps started the same way. If you wire up agent checkout this winter, plan for a fee once the volume is there.
- **United's safety reasons are real, but I don't think they're driving this.** The bag rule is a genuine problem for a bot. Kirby's middleman line points at the customer relationship instead. I'd bet United lets in verified agents within a year, once a rival's agent bookings show up in its numbers.
- **Keep the AI out of your menu photos.** A handful of posts on X this week had diners saying they'd walk out of a restaurant whose menu was full of generated food pictures. Nothing shows it costs anybody sales, so read it as how some people feel rather than as evidence. If you use AI on a menu at all, use it on the text agents read, like hours, prices and descriptions, and keep real photos for the people.
- **Nvidia's board shouldn't let a petition pick its next CEO.** Huang's allies are reportedly building a war room to lobby for his return, and some employees want him back. Loyalty to the founder of a $4 trillion company is understandable. The board should finish the investigation, then decide, and say out loud what it found.

## One Thing I'm Thinking About

This week I asked ChatGPT about Bull City AI the way a stranger might, and it gave a confident, friendly answer that included paid tiers. This newsletter is free and has no paid tiers. The model filled a gap with what newsletters usually have, and if I hadn't asked, I'd never have known.

Business Hub would never have shown me that. It counts mentions and clicks, not what ChatGPT actually says. Google has long told Business Profile owners to check their listing in a private browser window, and the same habit now applies to chatbots. Also, the links in ChatGPT's answer about us carried a utm\_source=chatgpt.com tag, so filter for that in your own analytics and see what turns up, then compare it with the hub's click count. OpenAI's help center also warns that a blank number in the hub doesn't necessarily mean nobody saw you.

Plenty of people are calling this the Google Business Profile moment for AI, and I expect the old listing-cleanup work to come back. This time most of it is reading what the chatbot says rather than fixing fields. Twenty minutes a month asking the five questions your customers actually ask, writing down what's wrong and fixing it on your own site is a good place to start.

![Bull City AI weekly newsletter illustration](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-restored-redbrick-tobacco_Sym1cZhUb8.png?width=1200)

## Local Angle: North Carolina Finally Gave Data Centers Their Own Rate Class

The ruling I've been waiting on since summer came Monday. The N.C. Utilities Commission approved Duke Energy's rate plans and, for the first time, set up a separate rate schedule for data centers that draw at least 50 megawatts, according to WRAL. Residential rates, starting Jan. 1, are projected to rise about 9.5% over two years for Duke Energy Carolinas and 9.3% for Duke Energy Progress, which serves Raleigh and much of eastern North Carolina. Duke gets a 9.8% return on equity, below the 10.95% it asked for.

Data centers on the new schedule pay demand charges on at least 75% of the power they contract for, even if they use less. Contracts run at least 10 years, or 15 for sites of 100 megawatts or more. They pay up front for equipment built only for them, owe exit charges if they leave early, and have to cut demand when the grid needs it. The Commission said Duke signed 6.7 gigawatts of contracts with new large customers in the Carolinas between March 2024 and April 2026, and 92% of that was data centers. Will Scott of the Environmental Defense Fund said the order helps make them "pay their fair share of the costs of connecting to the grid."

Attorney General Jeff Jackson asked for exactly this in September (#039). The settlement Duke signed with Amazon, Google, Meta and Microsoft didn't include it (#043). In #041 I wrote that a pledge is what a company offers when it hasn't decided yet, and a tariff is what it offers when someone made it decide. This week the Commission decided. Households still get a rate increase, though, and the same orders approved Duke's long-range plan with about 3,850 megawatts of new gas. The new schedule covers the cost of hooking data centers up to the grid. Who pays for the new power plants is still open.

For Triangle businesses, a couple of things from the Big Story are worth doing now. If you run a shop or a restaurant in the Triangle, you can only claim an existing ChatGPT listing for now, so search for your business before you assume you're not there. If you sell online, ask whoever runs your checkout whether its fraud rules would turn away an agent with a valid payment token.

## People Worth Following

- **Olivia Moore.** She co-wrote the B2A essay with Justine Moore at Andreessen Horowitz. Read it with the investor's lens on, since a16z backs companies in this space, but she pulls together consumer AI numbers as fast as anyone. [Read their B2A essay at a16z](https://a16z.com/welcome-to-the-b2a-economy/)
- **Ian Cutress.** He had the clearest read on Nvidia's quarter within hours, including the 14-week asterisk most headlines skipped. He writes about chips for people who read the footnotes. [Read his Nvidia breakdown at More Than Moore](https://morethanmoore.substack.com/p/nvidia-q3-fy27-a-record-quarter)
- **Will Scott.** He's the North Carolina policy director at the Environmental Defense Fund and has been weighing in on Duke's data center terms since the settlement in October. He'll be worth reading when the power plant fight starts. [Read his take in WRAL's story](https://www.wral.com/news/state/nc-approves-duke-energy-rate-hikes-new-rules-for-data-centers-november-2026/)

## Fine Print

- **The best argument against agents is a federal rule.** United's strongest point is the check-in step where a person has to confirm what's in the bag. Plenty of rules assume a human clicked the box. Expect agents to keep hitting laws written for people, and companies to cite them.
- **Nobody has said who pays when an agent buys the wrong thing.** OpenAI says Wallet keeps your existing card protections, but the launch materials don't fully cover refunds, returns or agent mistakes, as GadgetReview pointed out. And the work of not blocking agents by accident sits with the merchant.
- **Washington wants answers from Nvidia.** Congressional committees have asked for a briefing, and Sen. Elizabeth Warren is pressing Huang and the board directly. With a new Congress in January, expect it to become a hearing about chip security.

## What's Coming

- **Wednesday, Nov. 18.** Anthropic is expected to price its IPO this evening, per CNBC.
- **Thursday, Nov. 19.** ANT is expected to start trading on Nasdaq. The first price about a frontier lab that the lab doesn't set.
- **Friday, Nov. 27.** Black Friday, the first with ChatGPT Wallet live. Watch for stores declining agent purchases.
- **Tuesday, Dec. 1.** Gemini 4 Carbon and Argon prices double, to $4 and $20 per million tokens.

That's the week the middleman changed. See you next Wednesday.

Daniel

Bull City AI, Durham, NC

**P.S.** Ask ChatGPT about your own business this week, then hit reply and tell me the strangest thing it said. I'll share the pattern next week, with no names attached.

**P.P.S.** Forward this to whoever answers your front desk phone. Their next caller might be an agent.

## Share this post

<https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48><https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48><https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48><https://pinterest.com/pin/create/button/?url=https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48>[mailto:https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48](mailto:https%3A%2F%2Fbullcity.ai%2Fblog%2Fnewsletter%2Fedition-48)

## Keep reading

### [![Bull City AI weekly newsletter illustration](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/magnific_a-documentary-photograph-of-an-old-hanging-produce_UPtGTQnwny.png?width=3840&height=2160&name=magnific_a-documentary-photograph-of-an-old-hanging-produce_UPtGTQnwny.png) The public just set the price of AI | BullCity AI](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-47)

### [![Bull City AI weekly newsletter illustration](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/magnific__a-close-documentary-photograph-of-a-folded-college__63467.png?width=3840&height=2160&name=magnific__a-close-documentary-photograph-of-a-folded-college__63467.png) Your break from the election is a jersey patch | BullCity AI](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-46)

[![Bull City AI | Durham Circuit Bull](https://bullcity.ai/hs-fs/hubfs/freepik_assistant_1759412406030-1.png?width=1344&height=768&name=freepik_assistant_1759412406030-1.png "Bull City AI | Durham Circuit Bull")](https://bullcity.ai/)

- [Services](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-48#services)
- [Blog](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-48#blog)
- [About](https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-48#about)

<https://www.linkedin.com><https://www.facebook.com><https://www.twitter.com><https://www.instagram.com><https://www.tiktok.com>

---

Privacy Policy · Legal · © 2026 Bull City AI. All rights reserved.

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Daniel",
    "url" : "https://bullcity.ai/blog/author/daniel"
  },
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-18T14:57:58.000Z",
  "headline" : "The middleman just changed | BullCity AI",
  "image" : [ "https://bullcity.ai/hubfs/magnific_documentary-photograph-of-a-smalltown-diner-counter_cpgZuxY0eP.png" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://bullcity.ai/blog/newsletter/edition-48",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://bullcity.ai/hubfs/freepik_assistant_1759412406030-1.png"
    },
    "name" : "Bull City AI"
  }
}
```